|
| • Advanced Search • Help |
Dieppe | Year: 1993 Classification: Drama Actors/Actresses: - John N. Smith - Gary Reineke - Victor Garber Well acted drama gives realistic portrayal of Canadians I'll concentrate on the actual dramatic presentation rather than judging the technical merits of the DVD or its supporting features. The film itself is an accurate view of army life for the Canadians in England in WW II. Just about all facets of their existence at this time is covered; from the speed marches, poor food, boredom, and life at the pubs (as distinct from the beer parlours back home). The interaction of the senior commanders is well done, though those without a solid background of who was who in the Canadian Army may find the relationships of the characters a bit confusing at first. The personalities of historical figures like Victor Odlum (the un-named general in part I), Harry Crerar and Andy McNaughton are well captured. The Canadian actors who portray the British commanders like Mountbatten, Bailie-Grohman and Hughes-Hallett do so seemingly effortlessly; I was surprised to find out after the fact that these talented actors don't actually have the English and Scottish accents they used in the film. Minor historical details are incorrect such as insignia and weaponry but these are minor trifles and don't detract from the film; in fact many rare items of kit are showcased in the film also. The only glaring error is also a continuity shot; Mills bombs are showed being primed during the trip across the Channel, and then an American grenade without fuse is shown in an action shot, and two shots later the same grenade is shown, this time with grey putty covering the hole where the fuze should be! As for the history behind the raid, the book by Loring-Villa that this film is based on is an excellent read. The other reviewer who intimates that Dieppe provided valuable lessons learned hasn't asked himself - if Dieppe never happened, would Normandy have taken place any differently? As bitter as it may be to swallow, the casualties at Dieppe may very well have been in vain; certainly the Allies had many lessons to draw on from other invasions, from Gallipoli to Wake Island to Sicily and dozens of others, before the landings in Normandy. Dieppe was a stupid waste, and this movie explores why in an honest and intellectual manner. Best to read the book in conjunction. The characters of the Canadian infantry unit portrayed put a great human face on things, though a little more character development would have helped. Hard to fit everything into four hours though, and the interplay between Churchill and the others in that galaxy of generals is equally as interesting and important. A Cautionary Military Fable The Anglo-Canadian raid on the German-held port of Dieppe on 19 August 1942, known as Operation "Jubilee", was a tragic failure. Over 3,000 mostly Canadian soldiers were killed or captured in just over seven hours. The mini-series Dieppe attempts to recreate the events leading up to this tragedy on two levels: the men at high levels who argued for and planned the raid, and the soldiers at squad-level who had to execute it. As a war drama, Dieppe is relatively standard fare, following the traditional format of focusing on a squad of Canadian privates in the Royal Regiment of Canada, 2nd Canadian Division. This aspect of the film is very predictable, including romance angles (somehow, the movie industry feels that the portrayal of historical events would be unintelligible without a love triangle or two), and not particularly satisfying. The soldiers are introduced, prepare for the mission, wait and are then killed in a few moments of intense slaughter. The closing scene in Gallipoli is clearly mimicked, but without the suspense of waiting one's turn to be mown down. In Dieppe, they pretty much all die at one go. However the most interesting part of the mini-series and the most controversial, is in the way it assigns blame for this fiasco. The key man is Lord Louis Mountbatten, who was assigned to take over Combined Operations in October 1941. Mountbatten was ordered by Churchill to conduct commando raids on occupied Europe and to harass the enemy. Some of these raids were successful (and they are not mentioned in this film), others were not. In conjunction with other leaders, including General Montgomery, Mountbatten decided to launch a division-size raid on the port of Dieppe. No operation of this size had ever been attempted before. The mini-series portrays Mountbatten as the arrogant, amateurish villain of this tragedy, who uses the raid to supposedly promote his own selfish career interests. In fact, all the British senior planners in the raid, including Montgomery, are depicted as intense, idiotic and inflexible. They lie to the Canadians about the German defenses and the air and naval support that will be provided. On the other hand, the high-level Canadian army leaders are portrayed as a mixture of opportunists and victims. The corps commander volunteers his division to "do something" before the American army "steals the show". The senior Canadian commanders suspect the mission will flop but bite their lips. Major General Roberts, the division commander, is the most sympathetic character in the entire film, as first the division and then a difficult mission are dumped in his lap. Roberts is depicted as an honest, caring commander who wants to accomplish the mission and return with as many of his boys as possible. I strongly recommend professional army officers who are interested in joint operations to pay particular attention to Roberts role, because they are many genuine problems of interservice coordination laid bare therein. Un Curiosity led me to this... I'm not from Canada, but I do live about 45 miles from the Canadian border. If I remember correctly there is a Dieppe memorial park in Windsor, so I was always curious about the Dieppe raid. From what I understood it was a colossal messup and this movie seems to reinforce that. Dieppe makes the Arnhem thing look like a stroke of genius. It seems that everything was indicating this was going to be a colossal failure but the people in charge of the operation weren't paying attention, except for the Canadians. Anyways, it was nice to see a movie that showed some other belligerents besides the US, Britain, Germany and Russia. The DVD itself was a pretty good transfer, the picture was nice and crisp and the sound was pretty good for being made for TV. I wish US TV would do more stuff like this. Buy Dieppe at Amazon.com Buy posters at Allposters.com Jamster - the latest ringtones for your phone!  Search with Walhello on the Internet on Dieppe Search with the Priority Search Engine on Dieppe This page in other languages: Suomeksi | Nederlands | Deutsch
|
